Presented at a Psychology Seminar held in Basel,
Switzerland
What do Buddhist teachings say regarding happiness? I will
go into it from the broad view of an accomplisher (yogi)
in Diamond Way (Vajrayana) Buddhism.
In Buddhism, one basically
distinguishes between conditioned and unconditioned happiness,
between a relative and an absolute kind. Relative happiness
has to do with experiences; absolute happiness has to do with
the experiencer itself. When one watches the outer world —
the factories, streets, houses and cars — it is evident
they were made because beings wanted to experience something
pleasant. Hospitals and prisons, on the other hand, were built
in order to avoid certain types of suffering. Beings constantly
try to change outer conditions with the aim of receiving pleasant
feedback.
However, no matter how
beautiful houses, cars or landscapes may be, they cannot feel
happiness. The only thing that can ever be happy is mind.
What looks through our eyes and listens through our ears right
now is where it all happens. The usual attempts to base happiness
on outer factors are misplaced because the cause of this conditioned
happiness is transient in nature. It is as if one would try
to move something from a distance with a wobbly stick. This
is why every attempt to attain lasting happiness through conditioned
causes simply does not work.
Especially at the moment
of death it becomes very evident that "the last shirt
has no pockets," as we Danes say. At this time one cannot
take anything along and only lasting values count. Therefore,
it is wise to use one's time to find the causes of a truly
permanent happiness. Since everything conditioned, made or
born — by its very nature — is relative and impermanent,
it cannot last and must also fall apart again.
Beings who are unaware
of their timeless minds encounter three different kinds of
suffering:
First is the catastrophic
state where nothing works. For example, when one is totally
sick, half of one's family and friends are dying, everything
falls apart, and life is dramatic, painful and tragic.
The second kind of suffering
is often mistakenly considered happiness. It is the experience
of newness; that things constantly change. We may think, "Oh,
new pictures all the time, how exciting," until a moment
comes when we try to hold onto them. This, of course, can't
be done and in the end everything runs through our fingers
and we feel lost.
Finally, there is a third
kind of suffering that expresses itself as dissatisfaction
or frustration. It arises due to the fact that mind is nearly
always obscured. Most people don't even discover it since
they are too pre-occupied with the former kinds. One can hardly
remember yesterday and last week is already fading. There
are no memories of birth or former lives, and one does not
know what will happen in the future.
One or more of these
three types of suffering is always present until we recognise
them and start to exchange transient values with ones we can
really trust.
What can one truly rely
on in this world? Neither Materialism nor Nihilism. Today,
both of these main extreme philosophies have lost their scientific
basis. Both being and non-being cannot be proven and must
be seen as two sides of the same totality. Outer and inner
phenomena do not exist or non-exist. The way thoughts and
feelings come and go, the parts of the atom can be made to
disappear, while particles may appear again from apparently
empty space. If one looks for a real essence, the objects
disappear again. While if one tries to keep space empty, it
fills up on its own. When this is the case, what can one truly
rely on? What has the power to hold things?
There is only one thing
we can absolutely trust – the potential of space. Space
is much more than a black hole or nothingness. Often one knows
who is calling before one hears the voice on the phone. Letters
arrive from people whom one has recently thought strongly
about. This is not due to improved eyesight or hearing, but
to moments when we forget about being separate from the totality.
When we are simply there, nakedly open and resting in whatever
is going on, things happen. During such moments we not only
experience via our senses, but also through the vibration
of every atom in our body. Because space and energy inside
and out are expressions of the same totality, we are always
connected with everything.
In Buddhism, this is
called the "truth state" – Dharmakaya in the
Sanskrit language or Chöku in Tibetan. It means that
everything is part of the same totality. On another level,
a comparison can be made that space is like a container that
we are inside. However, this feeling of totality doesn't do
away with the necessity of judging the distance between things,
which is necessary for survival. Over the millennia, whoever
could judge the nearness of the tiger — or today, the
closeness of passing trucks — could usually survive
and pass on their genes. Many at first resist this understanding
of totality.
However, there is clearly
much more space behind things than between them. If one is
aware of the distance between the stars in space, even New
York is close. I advise trying to develop this viewpoint.
It is very important to see space as something that connects
beings and is alive; as a container which also conveys information
between things.
Space has more to it
than awareness alone and this is what makes it interesting
– it is also joyful. The radiance of mind itself is
much richer than the conditioned experiences of joy we all
strive for. The best moments in life are actually gifts and
appear when beings forget themselves. They are situations
where feelings of separation disappear, like being in the
arms of our loved ones – the timeless moment of "being
one." Here mind's innate, timeless joy can manifest,
and this will become permanent when one stays beyond hope
and fear in the richness of immediate experience. This state
is inseparable from mind's spontaneous insight and a transmission
of wisdom. This is a joyful experience – the basis of
everything outer and inner, and mind may even recognise itself
in the process.
Finally, because space
is unlimited, it expresses itself as love. This does not mean
kindness, where a Westerner from a highly developed society
may think one should help people in ghettos and other poor
parts of the world. This, of course is very good, especially
if it makes it possible for them to have fewer children. However,
it is only a shadow of the limitless experience where love
appears from the feeling of being one. When subject, object
and experience are a totality and we cannot separate our own
wishes for happiness from the wishes of others, one is in
the absolute state. Observing the world, this view feels exceedingly
natural. There can be no doubt that all beings want to be
happy and avoid suffering; that they are countless while the
observer is only one.
This full unfolding of
mind is based on Great Way (Mahayana) Buddhism and obtained
quickly through the countless skilful methods of Diamond Way
Buddhism. The three old schools of Tibetan Buddhism that use
meditation and transmission bring one especially quickly to
the state of the Great Seal (Mahamudra) or Great Perfection
(Maha-ati), where basis, way, and goal all become liberating.
Especially in the Kagyu Lineage, which I represent, the mirror
and its radiance are never separate. Space and bliss are understood
as one. What looks through our eyes and listens through our
ears is clear light and nothing external. However, it is not
something shiny like the light produced by a projector. It
is instead a constant state of freshness, an exciting 'here
and now' where momentary insights appear in direct connection
with the experience itself. When a steady "aha"
is united with every experience, this is true joy and the
goal.
Such a lasting state
will only be fully realised by examining who we really are,
and such analysis brings the conviction that one cannot essentially
be a body. Bodies change all the time. They were born, will
later die and are right now in a state of constant flux. Whatever
has no lasting nature cannot be a “self” or something
truly existent. The experience that they are not their bodies
at first amazes people, then actually becomes quite a relief.
Who wants to be something that gets old, sick and then dies?
Evidently, no transient body can be the basis of true happiness.
Some people then identify
with their thoughts and feelings, but this is even less convincing.
Our mental states change even more rapidly than their outer
containers. In Goethe's Faust during a dialogue between the
devil Mephisto and Faust, the former states that nothing changes
more quickly than the emotions of beings. Whoever identifies
with conditioned states of mind cannot avoid deep confusion.
The only feelings that are unchanging and timeless —
like the ocean beneath the waves — are fearlessness,
spontaneous joy and the compassion that motivates us to actually
do something to relieve the suffering of others. This is so
because these feelings appear from the one cause that never
changes – mind’s radiant and limitless space.
Only space is uncreated, indestructible and exists through
its own power. Space is a limitless container. Rich and playful
in its experiences, it effortlessly expresses compassion and
unites everything.
This is the goal of Buddha's
teachings. He wants beings to experience the mirror behind
the pictures, the vast ocean beneath the waves. Whoever can
experience themselves as aware radiance will be undisturbed
by the stream of what is known. The limitless joy alluded
to by the Buddha is attained by knowing mind itself. When
we arrive at the understanding that mind is neither born nor
created, everything in life is a gift.
When people have become
able to trust their inherent Buddha nature — their natural
state of mind — the Diamond Way Buddhist meditations
give the possibilities of working with mind through identification,
form or abstraction. The ones using “form” have
two phases – a building up phase, and a completion or
dissolving state.
Here different Buddhas
or teachers appear in front or above oneself as transparent
forms of energy and light. The feedback from these forms activates
and influences movements in the energy channels of the body.
This is extremely blissful and lays the seeds for beyond-personal
qualities and abilities to emerge. As the inspiration of the
Buddha aspect solidifies, one makes an additional vibration
bridge — a mantra — between oneself and the light-form.
Finally, one melts it into oneself as naturally as water flows
into water or light shines into light. Then all form disappears
and there is only awareness.
In its limitless space
beyond the experiencer or what is experienced, awareness is
without centre or limit, neither here nor there. Mind recognises
its countless qualities through its own power. This phase
is not intellectualised or forced. It is completely different
from Christian attempts to only think good, or the Hindu way
of trying not to think at all, which may dull mind. Evidently,
it is the total opposite to Moslem subjugation and submission.
By staying in the essence of what is aware, while allowing
impressions to come and go naturally without evaluating them,
one gains timeless insight. Before awareness becomes cloudy,
one again lets a fresh, radiant and new world appear and shares
the good impressions accumulated with all beings.
One aspect of Diamond
Way meditation is most profound and easily accessible through
the power of one’s wishes. It changes people on the
deepest levels and I teach it a dozen times around the world
every year. Known traditionally as ‘Phowa’, it
is the practice of Conscious Dying. Nine hundred and fifty
years ago, the Tibetan hero Marpa obtained the transmission
for this practice from his Indian teacher Naropa, and today
a method like this probably only exists in the three ‘old’
schools of Tibetan Buddhism. Here one learns how to control
the process of dying while still alive, so that later at death
one can send mind to the pure state of highest bliss.
This practice brings
about three types of signs. The first ‘outer’
sign is on the body and consists of an opening about eight
fingers behind the original hairline. It is usually a small
cut, or drop of blood, nothing large, but most sensitive to
touch. During the practice, many have the blissful experience
of freely leaving their bodies. The second or ‘inner’
sign develops into unforgettable states of freedom and certainty.
However, also mixed subconscious impressions appear while
the powerful practice activates the magnetic axis that runs
through the body. At this time, experiences of fear and insecurity
may arise in people, but when their own maturity and the Lama’s
power have evened the way, they report real fulfilment. The
third or ‘secret’ realisation is the certainty
that fear to a very high degree is no longer a hindrance.
It is the awareness that one’s essence is somehow indestructible,
that different kinds of suffering are now gone.
Through the practice
of Conscious Dying, ever more people get to rest in their
own centre and identify more with that which experiences,
than with the many objects of their experience. This is nothing
intellectual (everyone can very easily learn to say the right
words) but a total thing. We know beyond any doubt that body
and speech are our richness, and the means through which we
can benefit many beings. In this way, this experience grows
into an unshakable awareness of mind.
We understand there is
nothing to prove or excuse. We are that which is looking and
listening right now, that which experiences and is conscious.
It is then meaningless to let oneself be drawn from one’s
centre by fleeting events in the outer or inner ‘Disneyland.’
From a secure mental level, one uses body and speech to help
beings in their many passing and confused states. Being useful
to others from this level of fearless joy and compassion is
the real goal.
Buddha taught different
methods for getting there. For the less rebellious who would
prefer avoiding difficulties, he advised the way of renunciation
and becoming monks or nuns. This status gives social security;
one does not have to stand up to confrontation and is really
protected.
To those who aimed to
conquer life, who wanted to have experiences and leave a massive
track through the conditioned world, he advised the richness
of a lay life. Here, Buddha did not focus on what to avoid,
but on what is possible and attractive; on making life more
exciting and meaningful for others and ourselves.
The highest level of
teachings Buddha gave to the so-called “accomplishers”,
those developing on the level of “view”. In former
times they were called “yogis,” but this term
made too many people think of Hindus with turbans so I chose
a term that focuses on the result. This category includes
everybody who fearlessly and unconventionally strives for
enlightenment.
The point is to experience
everything on the level of highest purity. Here one understands
that it is not necessary to die to go to a pure land. That
one does not have to go elsewhere to meet Buddha. It is a
deeply satisfying insight that everybody’s mind is clear
light, even including the limited consciousness of a small
spider that can only react to a few square inches of web.
On top of that, if increasingly good karma enables one to
recognise everything as fresh and new, to feel every atom
vibrating with bliss and kept together by love, mind will
spontaneously express its joyful power. Happiness will be
lasting and it is only then a matter of confidence. Whoever
dares to trust their basic goodness, and jump from the images
into the mirror, is given every gift. As consciousness shifts
from the wave to the ocean, turning from the experiences to
the experiencer itself, there is only self-arisen joy.
A simple statement sums
it all up – “Behave like a Buddha until you become
one.” This means consciously lifting the level of one’s
perception, that it is only necessary to remove the dust from
one’s eyes to recognise in everything an expression
of love and self-arisen perfect wisdom. One will then see
that mind’s limitless potential is playing here and
now, as well as everywhere and always. Only this insight secures
absolute and lasting happiness, and Diamond Way Buddhist meditations
aim directly for that experience.
Two thousand five hundred
years ago, in accordance with the understanding of his time,
Buddha described his state as “the ending of suffering.”
Today, this is the wildest of understatements and we would
compare his experience to holding one’s fingers in an
electrical outlet and pulling the voltage of one’s town
through one’s bones. That intensity — inseparable
from the highest clarity and bliss — is the state we’re
talking about and this is also the reason why the Buddhas
of the highest Annutara Yoga Tantra state are always shown
in male-female union. This is the closest most people get
to that joy.
Three levels of meditation
co-operate to bring beings to this state. The first calms
and holds mind. It is comparable to a cup of coffee that is
no longer shaken – things naturally reflect themselves
in it. The second level works with our motivation. Here compassion
and wisdom nourish our absorption, involving more of our totality.
On the third and highest stage of identification, nothing
is left out. Its view and methods, blissful understanding,
power and deep confidence bring all of mind’s inherent
qualities to full maturation.
The first state reached
is called “one pointed.” Here, mind is rich and
needs nothing from anywhere else. It can stay happily wherever
it is. Then, secondly, one becomes “non artificial”
because the radiance of what is here and now goes beyond anything
one could even imagine. Thirdly, mind rests in the experience
of “one taste.” It is aware of itself in whatever
happens and the unshakable experiencer is felt through every
experience. The mirror is already more radiant than its pictures,
and it is more important that one can be conscious than whether
pleasant or unpleasant events occur. Finally, at the fourth
level of “no-meditation,” no conscious effort
is needed anymore. Without doubt or separation between subject,
object and action, one automatically fulfils what matures
beings in the long run.
As a bridge between cultures
and epochs, there is one last point in Buddha’s teachings
that must be quite liberating for psychologists and therapists
– that highest truth is highest joy, that truth on a
relative level is illusive. Most think that between rosy ups
and black-grey downs must exist something real, a reliable
level of truth. However, this was never discovered in the
conditioned world.
If one looks for
something really present and indestructible, one finds space.
Only from space does everything appear. Through its clarity
all things are known, and everything outer and inner returns
to its unlimited essence. Highest joy, love, power, courage,
energy, wisdom and insight all perfect each other. In other
words, we have a real assurance – the highest level
of function is the highest level of truth. The better one
feels, the smoother everything moves, the more exciting aspects
of mind appear, the nearer one comes to the Buddha-state.
There is only one difference between a Buddha and others.
He has developed all qualities of body, speech and mind. Everybody
can do exactly the same, and both way and goal are good.
|